- PZ Myers (Pharyngula): Roy Varghese and the exploitation of Antony Flew
- Richard Carrier (RCs Blogs): Antony Flew's Bogus Book
Carrier claims that the book isn't written by Flew -- it is written as comtemporary Christian apologetics.
- Mark Perakh (Talk Reason): Flew, Schroeder, Varghese: What a company!
Perakh tones down the conversion; deists are really just a variety of atheists.
- William Dembski (Uncommon Descent): I Liked the Old Atheists Better
Dembski prefers the intellectual honesty and civility of an old-school atheist like Antony Flew for the crass and unruly behavior of the newer varietysuch as Richard Dawkins. Add to that the Flew is no longer an atheist.
The article is followed by a message from Flew stating that he stands by the book. It was written by Varghese, because Flew is too old to write, but he has read the book and claims that it is his words.
Myers mainly quotes Oppenheimer for the mental decline of Antony Flew.